The Frank Sinatra Show (1950-1952)
By Jim Davidson Posted
10/15/2006 Updated 11/11/2007
New
York Times ad for Sinatra's first TV show |
Sinatra's
Ratings - The Real Story While
it's true that The Frank Sinatra Show wasn't able to best Your Shows
of Shows and Milton Berle's Texaco Star Theater in the ratings race,
its showing - at least according to CBS - wasn't that bad. For October 23, 1951,
Berle had a 41.6 Trendex rating, while Sinatra scored a 16.3. In its pitch to
potential sponsors the week of November 7 that year, CBS pointed out that their
man did better than 64 other apparently successful shows - like Ted Mack's Original
Amateur Hour, Groucho Marx's You Bet Your Life, and Martin Kane,
Private Eye. The sponsors were unconvinced. But perhaps most telling is that
Sinatra managed to chip away enough of Berle's rating to knock him down from first
place in the 1950-51 season to second the following year. It was the beginning
of the end of Berle's dominance of television. | |
|
It was a low point in
the singer's career. His record sales declining, dumped by his movie studio, his
radio series cancelled, and perhaps most frighteningly, sidelined for over a month
with a ruptured vocal cord, Frank Sinatra was in the depths of despair. He was
dogged by bad press, due to an affair with movie star Ava Gardner while still
married to first wife Nancy. It didn't help that his thin skin and ill temper
(not to mention an overindulgence in alchohol) sometimes fueled violent confrontations
with reporters and photographers he felt had wronged him. So
it was that, in 1950, Sinatra found himself casting about for a vehicle that could
help him resusitate his career. Television was the new thing and had helped a
number of has-been entertainers, so why not give it a try? Following
a well-received appearance on Bob Hope's TV show on May 27th, the struggling singer
signed with CBS for dual television and radio shows to begin in the fall. The
radio show, Meet Frank Sinatra (later retitled Here's Frank Sinatra)
aired on Sunday afternoons. The TV program, entitled The Frank Sinatra Show,
featured longtime musical director Axel Stordahl, singer June Hutton (Stordahl's
wife), comedian Ben Blue, and a succession of vocal groups. The
show was plagued with problems right off the bat, suffering from disappointing
ratings, a high turnover in personnel, and a shortage of sponsor support. Scheduled
on Saturday nights opposite the formidable Your Shows of Shows, Sinatra
had trouble drawing viewers. In an effort to shore up the ratings, CBS kept replacing
the producer and director, but it didn't help. (In
one comedy sketch, Sinatra quipped that sidekick Ben Blue "changes costumes
faster than I change producers.") There
was also turnover in the cast. Reportedly unhappy with the way his talents were
being used, Blue left in January 1951. Sinatra wanted to replace him with Jackie
Gleason, but the comic was then busy hosting Cavalcade of Stars on the
Dumont network and that show's sponsor wouldn't let him go. (Gleason did manage
to get clearance, though, to make a series of guest appearances.) The
Sinatra show ran on a sustaining basis (meaning it had no sponsor) until November
1950, when the Bulova watch company signed on - but only for the first half-hour.
Bulova pulled out at the end of the season, and it began to look as if the show
wouldn't return in the fall. But at the last minute, CBS managed to convince Ekco
Products (a housewares company) to sponsor one-quarter of the show. Unfortunately
for Sinatra, the network moved the program to Tuesdays at 8:00 pm - opposite Milton
Berle's Texaco Star Theater, an even bigger ratings powerhouse than Your
Show of Shows. "The
Voice" was no match for Uncle Miltie, and in January 1952, Ekco dropped out.
With the exception of a single episode, the program remained sponsorless for the
rest of the season. At a cost of $41,500 an episode - an estimated total loss
to CBS of a million dollars - the show was just too expensive to continue, and
the network cancelled it. Things
would get worse for the singer before they got better. Sinatra's radio show had
been cancelled in July 1951, and he now not only didn't have a TV show but would
soon lose his contract with Columbia Records. He had managed to convince his wife
to give him a divorce so he could marry Ava Gardner in November 1951. But life
with Ava was stormy, and the bad press continued. With little work available,
Frank's financial situation became so desperate that he was reduced to borrowing
money from his new bride. Despite
the disappointing ratings, Sinatra's first foray into television wasn't bad. The
star was, of course, a fine singer at the peak of his powers. The comedy material
wasn't always the best, but even when a joke was a dud, Sinatra usually had enough
comic flair to pull it off. Perhaps most fascinating is that, even with all the
turmoil in his personal life and career, Frank copes surprisingly well. His greatest
period was just around the corner, and though not yet fully realized, the seeds
of that greatness are very much in evidence. | |
Sources: The New York Times TV listings and reviews, Variety
reviews and articles, and the episodes themselves. I'm also grateful to David
Schwartz, TV Historian for Game Show Network
and co-author of the Encyclopedia
of TV Game Shows (paid link), for providing announcer and studio information. |
Season
1 (1950-1951) Saturday, 9:00-10:00
pm, CBS-TV, Sponsor: Bulova |
Series
# |
Season
# |
Airdate |
Cast |
001 |
1-01 |
10/7/1950 |
J. Carrol Naish, Ben Blue,
Mary Mayo, tap dancers Harrison and Kaye, The Moon Mists, Axel Stordahl and his
Orchestra Note: Frank sings "When You're Smiling" and "Ol'
Man River." In a pantomime sketch, Ben appears as Charlie Chaplin, with Frank
as The Kid. J. Carrol Naish was the star of the popular Life With Luigi
on radio, and plays the title character here in a sketch that provides viewers
with a preview of what the show might look like in the new medium. (Life With
Luigi didn't actually make it to TV until 1952.) Variety believed that
Sinatra had potential as a TV host but that CBS had saddled him with "bad
pacing, bad scripting, bad tempo, poor camera work and an overall jerky presentation."
Jack Gould of The New York Times declared, "Frank Sinatra walked off
the television high dive on Saturday night, but unfortunately fell into the shallow
end of the pool." The show begins on a sustaining (no sponsor) basis. According
to David Schwartz, the announcer was Ken Roberts. |
002 |
1-02 |
10/14/1950 |
Brian Aherne, Ben Blue,
Mary Mayo, Sid Fields, dancers Condos and Brandow, The Whipoorwills Note:
Following a disastrous premiere, producer Paul Dudley is replaced by Irving Mansfield,
and John Peyser succeeds Hal Gerson as director. Apparently, the changes helped
because Variety reported, "The second program had purposes, design,
movement and carried good entertainment values." The New York Times
lists The Moon Mists as this week's vocal group, but Variety reports that
it was The Whipoorwills. |
003 |
1-03 |
10/21/1950 |
Mary McCarty, Lou Wills Jr., Roberta Lee, Ben Blue and Family, Mary Mayo, The
Whipoorwills Note: With this episode, the show seemed to have finally gotten
on track. Variety found it "a fine blend of song, dance and comedy,
all neatly produced, scripted and staged." Frank sings "Soliloquy"
from Carousel, and Mary does a 42nd Street routine. The show runs
90 seconds short, so the star has to ad lib. |
004 |
1-04 |
10/28/1950 |
Ben Blue, The Moon Mists, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra |
005 |
1-05 |
11/4/1950 |
Nancy
Walker, Teddy Hale, Ben Blue, the Club Savannah revue, The Whipoorwills Note:
Frank and Nancy sing "Let's Go To My Place" from On the Town.
Variety complained that the show had lost its groove and the cast "couldn't
overcome the basically non-inventive material." But it did like a sketch
in which Frank plays the star of a private detective radio show, with Ben as the
incompetent sound effects man. |
006 |
1-06 |
11/11/1950 |
Ben
Blue and Family, Roberta Lee, Bob Sweeney and Hal March, acrobats The Asia Boys,
The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra Note: Marlo Lewis and John
Wray take over as producer and director, respectively, for this one episode. Frank
does a takeoff on the song "Everything Happens to Me," with lyrics describing
TV's pitfalls. Also included is a re-creation of the star's 1945 anti-discrimination
short The House I Live In. |
007 |
1-07 |
11/18/1950 |
Patricia
Morison, Jan Murray, Ben Blue and Family, The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and
his Orchestra Note: Jack Donahue takes over as producer-director. Bulova begins
its sponsorship of half the show, intially for five weeks. |
008 |
1-08 |
11/25/1950 |
Sarah
Vaughan, Johnny Coy, Ben Blue and Family, The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and
his Orchestra |
009 |
1-09 |
12/2/1950 |
Milton
Berle, Toni Arden, Ben
Blue and Family, The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra |
010 |
1-10 |
12/9/1950 |
Jackie
Gleason, June Hutton, Joe Bushkin and his Trio, Ben Blue and Family, The Whipoorwills,
Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra |
011 |
1-11 |
12/16/1950 |
Phil
Silvers, Ben Blue and Family, Sid Fields, Roberta Lee, The Whipoorwills, Axel
Stordahl and his Orchestra Note: Variety called this "one of the
best programs to date," crediting "a greater awareness of tele values
by Sinatra and his production staff and the guesting of Phil Silvers" for
the improvement. Frank was a busy boy this night, as he guest starred on The
Jack Carter Show (on NBC-TV) from 8:00 to 9:00 pm. |
012 |
1-12 |
12/23/1950 |
Walter
Slezak, Toni Harper, Ben Blue and Family (Roberta Lee, Sid Fields, Leslie Lyons,
Pat Gaye, Joey Walsh), The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra Note:
Frank sings "Jingle Bells," "Try a Little Tenderness," "O
Come All Ye Faithful," "I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm," "Winter
Wonderland," and "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas." A bunch
of kids join him for "Silent Night." 13-year-old Toni sings "Goldilocks
and the Three Bears" and duets with Frank on "Button Up Your Overcoat."
The Whipoorwills perform a medley of Gay 90s songs. Susquehanna Waist Company
sponsors fifteen minutes of this single episode. Bulova extends its half-hour
sponsorship for the remainder of the season. |
013 |
1-13 |
12/30/1950 |
Garry
Moore, Ben Blue and Family, The Whipoorwills, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra |
014 |
1-14 |
1/6/1951 |
June
Hutton, Buster West, Ben Blue and Family, The Heathertones, The Whipoorwills,
Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra |
015 |
1-15 |
1/13/1951 |
Jackie Gleason, June Hutton,
Buster West, dancers Tato and Julia, The Heathertones Note: Variety
praised Gleason's contribution, noting that it was "sufficiently integrated
to push the pace up a few notches and at the same time doesn't detract from Sinatra's
star status." |
016 |
1-16 |
1/20/1951 |
Laraine
Day, Leo Durocher, Phil Foster Note: According to the Los Angeles Times,
in place of a live appearance by Bing Crosby, Frank talks to a cardboard cutout
of "the groaner," while a recording of Crosby's voice is heard. Baseball
great Durocher was Laraine Day's husband. |
017 |
1-17 |
1/27/1951 |
Phil
Silvers, June Hutton, Jack Goode, Ollie Frank, Harold Stone, Muriel Landers
Note: This same night The Jack Carter Show featured former Sinatra cast
members Ben Blue and The Whipoorwills. Jack Donahue hands over the producer's
job to Marlo Lewis but remains as director. |
018 |
1-18 |
2/3/1951 |
Jackie
Gleason, June Hutton, The Heathertones, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra Note:
Jackie sells Frank his newly-inherited "hunting lodge" in the mountains,
sight unseen, and the two invite June and the Heathertones to join them there
for the weekend. Frank sings "It Had To Be You," "Take My Love,"
"Everything Happens to Me," "Let It Snow, Let It Snow, Let It Snow,"
"My Heart Stood Still," and "I Am Loved." June joins him for
"You'd Be So Nice To Come Home To" and then solos on "I Feel a
Song Comin' On." June and The Heathertones sing "Zip-a-dee Doo Dah"
and The Heathertones do "They Couldn't Catch Me" on their own. An unbilled
actress (who plays the heavyset woman) sings "I Wanna Be Loved." A Valentine-themed
Bulova commercial places this episode close to February 14th, but while the New
York Times TV listing for the 3rd lists Jackie Gleason, it also includes Jack
Goode and Ollie Frank, who don't appear. Jack Donahue is both producer and director. |
019 |
1-19 |
2/10/1951 |
Barbara
Britton, June Hutton, Jack Goode, Ollie Frank, The Heathertones |
020 |
1-20 |
2/17/1951 |
Faye
Emerson, Skitch Henderson, Arthur Blake, Irving Kupcinet |
021 |
1-21 |
2/24/1951 |
Douglas
Fairbanks Jr., Jean Carroll, Teddy Hale, June Hutton, The Heathertones |
022 |
1-22 |
3/3/1951 |
Perry
Como, Frankie Laine, Betty and Jane Kean, June Hutton, ballroom dancers The Digatanos,
The Heathertones, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra; cameo by The Andrews Sisters
Note: Crooners Sinatra, Como, and Laine join forces to provide a generous helping
of first rate fun. "Trio didn't need brilliant lines," explained Variety,
"because of the general aura of easy entertainment they provided. They did
some well-written parodies of themselves which had a line of nice and easy humor
running throughout." Frank sings "I Get a Kick Out Of You," Perry
does "If," and Frankie performs "That Lucky Old Sun." Following
a satire by the singers on The Andrews Sisters, the sisters themselves appear
to belt them with their handbags. |
023 |
1-23 |
3/10/1951 |
Joan
Blondell, Don Ameche, June Hutton, The Heathertones |
024 |
1-24 |
3/17/1951 |
Jackie
Gleason, Mary McCarty, June Hutton, The Heathertones |
025 |
1-25 |
3/24/1951 |
Denise
Darcel, Basil Rathbone |
026 |
1-26 |
3/31/1951 |
Peggy
Lee, Conrad Nagel, Jack Gilford, dancers Mary Raye and Naldi Note: Peggy sings
"Mañana" and Frank does a reprise of The House I Live In. As
reported by Variety, someone in the audience familiar with Frank's act
yells out the punchline of a joke before he can deliver it. |
027 |
1-27 |
4/7/1951 |
Dagmar,
Frank Fontaine, Harry Slate, June Hutton, The Heathertones |
028 |
1-28 |
4/14/1951 |
Rudy
Vallee, The Pied Pipers |
029 |
1-29 |
4/21/1951 |
Smith
and Dale, Al Bernie |
030 |
1-30 |
4/28/1951 |
Dagmar,
Frank Fontaine, Henry Slate |
031 |
1-31 |
5/5/1951 |
Dagmar, Tim Herbert and Don Saxon,
Eileen Barton, Joe Bushkin, June Hutton, Axel Stordahl and his Orchestra Note:
Frank sings "When You're Smiling," "Hello Young Lovers," and
"If," and he and June duet on "My Romance." Joe performs "I
Love a Piano," and Eileen joins him for "I Wanna Hang My Hat On a Tree
That Grows in Brooklyn." Eileen
sings "What Do You Think I Am?," followed by Frank doing "Oh Look
At Me Now" (with modified lyrics and a slight assist from Eileen). Dagmar
sings "Ballin' the Jack," while Tim and Don do "Carolina in the
Morning" and "Liza." At the time, Frank was appearing with his
guest stars at the Paramount Theatre in New York City.
|
032 |
1-32 |
5/12/1951 |
Jackie
Gleason |
033 |
1-33 |
5/19/1951 |
Phil
Silvers |
034 |
1-34 |
5/26/1951 |
J.
Carrol Naish, Phil Foster |
035 |
1-35 |
6/2/1951 |
Phil
Silvers, June Hutton |
036 |
1-36 |
6/9/1951 |
June
Hutton |
| |
|
Replaced
for the summer by Faye Emerson's Wonderful Town |
|
|
Season
2 (1951-1952) Tuesday, 8:00-9:00
pm, CBS-TV, Sponsor: Ekco Products |
Series
# |
Season
# |
Airdate |
Cast |
037 |
2-01 |
10/9/1951 |
Perry
Como, Frankie Laine, The Andrews Sisters, Broderick Crawford, Axel Stordahl and
his Orchestra Note: Max Gordon is the new producer, while Marlo Lewis continues
as executive producer. Ekco Products takes over sponsorship of the first quarter
hour of the show. The rest is sustaining. Variety found this show "spotty,
taking full advantage of its all-star talent lineup to sparkle in some spots and
settling down to a slow walk in others." Jack Gould of The New York Times
credited the star with "a very real degree of stage presence and a certain
likeable charm" but felt "the evening's honors were captured effortlessly
and smoothly by another gentleman, Perry Como." |
038 |
2-02 |
10/16/1951 |
Jackie
Gleason, Anne Jeffreys, dancers Stanton and Luster |
039 |
2-03 |
10/23/1951 |
Dagmar,
Mary McCarty, Jack E. Leonard |
040 |
2-04 |
10/30/1951 |
Georgia
Gibbs, Jules Munshin, Eddie Mayehoff Note: Jules Munshin co-starred with Frank
and Gene Kelly in On the Town (1949). |
041 |
2-05 |
11/6/1951 |
Jackie
Gleason, June Hutton, Grady Sutton, Pert Kelton, Roberta Lee, dancers Stanton
and Luster Note: In a change of pace, this episode features a "book"
musical about two private detectives looking to recover a stolen $100,000. "Sinatra
did evidence again, though, how far he's come as a straight man and comedian,"
noted Variety. "He traded gags on even terms with Gleason and, when
some props failed to function properly, he was right in there with what sounded
like ad libs, too." The day following this episode, Frank married movie star
Ava Gardner. (His divorce from first wife Nancy Barbato had become final on October
29th.) |
042 |
2-06 |
11/13/1951 |
Jack
Benny, June Hutton, 10-year-old violinist Charles Castleman, Larry Griswold, Axel
Stordahl and his Orchestra Note: In New York for a Friars Club Dinner, Jack
Benny guest starred on several CBS TV shows, including this one. His appearance
was meant to reciprocate for Frank guesting on his show January 28, 1951. Variety
found that Frank and his guest, "kidding each other's known idiosyncracies
for laughs, sparked the show into one of the better ones he's done this season."
Frank sings "I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm," "My Concerto,"
"For You," and a reprise of "The House I Live In." June sings
"You Do Something To Me." |
043 |
2-07 |
11/20/1951 |
Laraine
Day, Leo Durocher, June Hutton, Jimmy Boyd Note: This was Sinatra's first
show to originate from Hollywood. According to David Schwartz, it broadcast from
Studio A at CBS's Columbia Square facility, and Bob Lemond (who had previously
worked on Ed Wynn's show) was the new announcer. Danny
Dare takes over as producer. |
044 |
2-08 |
11/27/1951 |
Arlene
Dahl, George Tobias, Mike Mazurki, Jimmy Boyd, Mari Blanchard, Lenny Kent |
045 |
2-09 |
12/4/1951 |
Marie
Wilson |
046 |
2-10 |
12/11/1951 |
The
Andrews Sisters, Roger Price, Joan Holloway, Henry Slate |
047 |
2-11 |
12/18/1951 |
Eddie
Anderson, Eric Blore, Alan Mowbray, June Hutton, Lenny Kent |
048 |
2-12 |
12/25/1951 |
Edmund
Gwenn, Marilyn Maxwell, Jimmy Boyd, The Dunhills |
049 |
2-13 |
1/1/1952 |
Yvonne
De Carlo, Louis Armstrong, The Three Stooges, George DeWitt, Axel Stordahl and
his Orchestra; cameo by Alan Young Note: Frank throws a New Year's party,
with The Three Stooges as his butlers. Frank sings "A Great Day" and
"Oh! Look At Me Now" (with new "morning after" lyrics that
include the line, "You're in trouble, friends, when Ava starts to look like
Marjorie Main."). Louis sings and plays "I'm Confessin'," while
Yvonne performs "Babalu" (in Spanish). Frank and Yvonne get together
for "Getting To Know You," and Frank and Louis duet on "Lonesome
Man Blues." George does impressions of singers Perry Como, Mel Tormé, Vaughn
Monroe, Billy Eckstine, and Billy Daniels. Frank plays Alladin in a magic lamp
sketch. |
050 |
2-14 |
1/8/1952 |
Alan
Young, Tennessee Ernie, Jimmy Boyd Note:
Ekco Products drops its sponsorship, and except for February 12th, the show is
sustaining for the rest of its run.
|
051 |
2-15 |
1/15/1952 |
Denise
Darcel |
052 |
2-16 |
1/22/1952 |
George
McManus, Beatrice Kay, Buster Keaton, Joe Laurie Jr., The Bell Sisters Note:
The Bell Sisters were seen frequently on early 1950s variety shows. In this, their
first network TV appearance, they perform their hit song "Bermuda."
Cartoonist George McManus was the creator of Maggie and Jiggs in the comic strip
Bringing Up Father. |
053 |
2-17 |
1/29/1952 |
Dick
Haymes, Tom D'Andrea, Larry Blake, Patti Moore, Ben Lessy |
054 |
2-18 |
2/5/1952 |
Diana
Lynn, Frank Fontaine, Ann Triole |
055 |
2-19 |
2/12/1952 |
Buster
Keaton, Zsa Zsa Gabor, The Delta Rhythm Boys, June Hutton Note: Elgin-American
sponsors fifteen minutes of this single episode, as part of its pre-Valentine's
Day sales effort. |
056 |
2-20 |
2/19/1952 |
James
Mason, Pamela Kellino, Jackie Coogan |
057 |
2-21 |
2/26/1952 |
Zsa
Zsa Gabor, Yma Sumac, Frank Fontaine, Leon Belasco, The Mandarines |
058 |
2-22 |
3/4/1952 |
Cass Daley, Liberace |
059 |
2-23 |
3/11/1952 |
The
Andrews Sisters, Jimmy Boyd, Larry Griswold |
060 |
2-24 |
3/18/1952 |
Victor Borge, Borah Minevitch's Rascals,
June Hutton |
061 |
2-25 |
3/25/1952 |
Nancy
Walker, Frank Fontaine, June Hutton |
062 |
2-26 |
4/1/1952 |
Frank
Fontaine, June Hutton, The Diagoras |
| |
|
Replaced
by The Sam Levenson Show and Draw to Win |
|
Copyright
2006 by Jim Davidson. All Rights Reserved.
|